What Creepypastas would be good to put in a vlog?

I need more creepy-pastas in my series that would make sense in the plot to make it more interesting. What do you think I should have in my series? My series has just ended Season 1,so I want to introduce more antagonists and protagonists in Season 2.

Add Jeff the Killer or of course the classic Rake

No Jeff 'cause he doesn't concentrate on one victim to kill. The Rake has already been too over used.

Well okay what about The Seed Eater

Planned already...

Okay well I am out of ideas

Don't know if it would work in your series, but I have always wanted to see/do a vlog based off of BEN DROWNED. Imagining that it would start as a Let's Play channel with an LP of Majora's Mask, and then developing from there. However, hacking a rom to make the BEN effects is way out of my league. Always something I wanted to do though.

DuaLocKs wrote:

No Jeff 'cause he doesn't concentrate on one victim to kill. The Rake has already been too over used.

How is the rake over used? I only saw two vlogs (EMH and WhisperedFaith) that have him in it.I don't know if there's any blogs about the rake.No,Jeff the killer wouldn't work in a vlog.

Chieftain1 wrote:

DuaLocKs wrote:

No Jeff 'cause he doesn't concentrate on one victim to kill. The Rake has already been too over used.

How is the rake over used? I only saw two vlogs (EMH and WhisperedFaith) that have him in it.I don't know if there's any blogs about the rake.No,Jeff the killer wouldn't work in a vlog.

StanFrederickBTS, EveryManHYBRID, WhisperedFaith, thedeletedgoomba, etc.

Didn't know the deleted goomba had the rake it.

Chieftain1 wrote:

I only saw two vlogs (EMH and WhisperedFaith) that have him in it.

My vlog has him in it

Anyway, do what I do and put unexplained subtle pastas in there if you want. I find that BOB, Stiltwalker, Jeff the killer and the Pocket are the best one's for creepy value. Another thing you could look into is a pasta about these little monsters called Gristers. Basically when you start seeing 'em they are harmless little midget monsters, but if you video tape them or photograph them then they start showing up in more numbers, greater sizes, and are more hostile. It would make for a few cool plot points to keep filming but have to avoid getting them in full view of the camera. Originally I was going to put them in as the main annoying subtagonist, but I do not have the tools or time needed to make them I guess. Anyway, I've watching your series and it's really good, so just put what you find works best in the long run of your plot.

I really don't know which would be good. It all depends on how well you can portray them based on what little information we get on the little creepers and what you can create based on their stories.
With that being said, unless you re-write the Jeff the Killer story, do not use Jeff the Killer.