I think TTA is a collective, the videos don't seem to match up in style necessarily, nor do the hints, certain ones are similar, and like, groups of them follow one MO and then others another so...
I've got it!
[theory]
Spoiler:
ToTheArk is a cultist following of Jay from the future, because Jay ends up somehow defeating The Operator and is looked upon as a savior. However, Jay dies defeating The Operator and these people somehow "slingshotted" using The Operator's ability to warp time (Entry 20-something, I'll link later and edit) and are trying to save Jay from dying while trying to figure out a way to defeat The Operator withing Jay dying.
Probably wrong. But how cool would it be if that was it?
EDIT:
This Entry is what I was talking about:
Wrathling Untainted
Posts : 44 Current Win Points : 12 Join date : 2011-03-07 Age : 32 Location : Tennessee
Why is it almost every time I sleep normally... TTA posts. Anyway, I'm not really sure what to think yet. I have't really stopped to really examine it. I'll do that later on today.. But I agree with Zander, maybe TTA is the operator?
Apples Anxious
Posts : 84 Current Win Points : 7 Join date : 2011-03-23
Also I figured the numbers at the beginning were entry numbers and the 40 at the end signified something big going down next entry. But it was a secret code instead! I dunno TTA, are you a prophet?
MadameMiz Watched
Posts : 205 Current Win Points : 114 Join date : 2011-02-11 Age : 33 Location : North Carolina
Eh, dividing the numbers by 2? Seems too weird and out there. I lol'd cause he forgot to put the last three numbers properly divided in the second line.
Otherwise, creepy fucking video. And a theory.
TTA = The Operator?
BEFORE YOU JUMP ON MY ASS: I think it was Slendy that was outside his car. I still think so. And this only makes me shit more bricks. Maybe Slendy/The Operator can visually record things with his "eyes"? And another theory. What if the Operator Symbols can function as The Operator's eyes? He can "see" you through them and is always watching you with the symbols?
I was thinking of the same thing, since so many people were saying the figure outside Jay's car was Slendy. It's very possible, and if it's the case, I think this has large ramifications for Slendy's mental processes and personality.
I also love the idea that the Operator symbol is Slendy's eye. Especially because so many of his victims draw it. It's like self-sabotage!
Hellebore Anxious
Posts : 63 Current Win Points : 17 Join date : 2010-12-11
I was still a bit too groggy when I first watched this one.. As for the previous marble hornets entry, it did look a lot like Slendy.. or rather someone trying really hard to look like Slendy.. While tall... it didnt seem quiet 'stretched out' enough looking. And it was walking strange, and awkwardly. Maybe someone decided to scare Jay by pretending to be Slenderman? (cough, Alex?) I like the theory of TTA being more than one person. After all, several times TTA refers to itself as 'we' and there seems to be more than one person involved. Perhaps one of the TTA crew (Maybe Alex?) dressed as Slendy and recorded Alex, one of the others decided to reveal it had been done? That could prove interesting, if Jay has support and is getting help from one member and not from others?
ChaosGamma Observer
Posts : 188 Current Win Points : 26 Join date : 2011-04-05 Age : 32 Location : Where I need to be
I don't think Totheark can be the Operator, since "Return" shows the Operator walking towards whoever's filming.
Which means I could've been wrong about the Operator being who we saw in Entry 39. Totheark is trying to look like the Operator? Watching it again I can also see what somebody mentioned, that it looks like he's holding something. I don't know, it's way too blurry to tell anything.
LisaEvermore Taken
Posts : 439 Current Win Points : 139 Join date : 2010-12-12 Age : 35 Location : I'm not sure
I think that it should be noted that should TTA=/=Operator, he makes nearly the same movement and takes the same path. It appears to be in the same parking lot on the same night, so even if they are not the same person, TTA is directly in contact with the Operator.
But
Spoiler:
I still stand by my original theory as to why he was called the Operator... I.e. Camera Operator.
Just sayin'.
Slynesh Anxious
Posts : 83 Current Win Points : 40 Join date : 2011-02-15 Age : 34 Location : Numerous places.....
Subject: Re: New TTA; Forecast Sat Apr 23, 2011 1:53 am
I can't even begin to make something out of this. It's just so damn frustrating that there is NO way to know who exactly it was that watched Jay OTHER than hurp it was TTA.
Needless to say I is confused...
PARADOX intent Watched
Posts : 263 Current Win Points : 56 Join date : 2011-01-28 Age : 34 Location : Sacramento, California
Subject: Re: New TTA; Forecast Sat Apr 23, 2011 2:16 am
....I got the notice for this video through my email.
I'm not gonna lie, seeing that little bit of text, "totheark just uploaded a video" made my heart skip a beat, and my toes curl. I was sincerely freaked out/excited for this.
Nice to see that TTA still lives up to the fact that he has yet to disappoint.
However, he also lives up to the fact that he confuses the hell out of me.
It would seem as though our little film-critic friend has some explaining to do. I've heard several viable theories, like he's more than one person, he could be SlenderMan..etc.
Now, he could have shown up after the man/person/thing in the last MH entry, but I just realized that he might have shown up on Jay's tape. *facepalm* So, yeah. According to the footage, and corresponding with Jay's footage, he had to have been the one there in Entry #39.
So, more mysteries abound. Excuse my rambling. Writing/typing things out help me think.
EDIT: Just read Blackwolf's post.
Spoiler:
That would be hilarious if SlenderMan is just curious, and he's mimicking Jay to discover just WTF it is he's doing. XD
Last edited by PARADOX intent on Sat Apr 23, 2011 2:19 am; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : OSHI-)
Pryex Observer
Posts : 142 Current Win Points : 25 Join date : 2011-01-23 Age : 30 Location : Planet England
Subject: Re: New TTA; Forecast Sat Apr 23, 2011 7:55 am
There is only one plausable explanation:
TTA IS Masky, and Slendy was giving him a piggyback ride.
Spoiler:
But seriously that's creepy as hell and I don't know what's goign on anymore
AlanAuch Observer
Posts : 162 Current Win Points : 34 Join date : 2010-12-12 Age : 41
Subject: Re: New TTA; Forecast Sat Apr 23, 2011 9:41 am
Apples wrote:
For me three things:
1. I'm so glad there was a totheark response after Jay's Twitter told me otherwise.
I'm pretty used to the idea by now that if Jay says "there's not going to be a TTA vid", there is sure as shit going to be a TTA vid
ChaosGamma Observer
Posts : 188 Current Win Points : 26 Join date : 2011-04-05 Age : 32 Location : Where I need to be
Subject: Re: New TTA; Forecast Sat Apr 23, 2011 9:51 am
So my former theory was that Tim, Alex and the Operator were each working against each other for.... whatever. Maybe Totheark is a fourth party? Or I suppose Tim and Totheark could be separate but still working together.
Going back to the Return video, that might actually make sense since it appears Tim was the one that took Jay back to the house and Totheark posted it.
Hell, I don't even know. I was sure it was the Operator in Entry 39, but now it has to be Totheark and I still say Totheark can't be the Operator. Unless all three of them are actually working together against Alex?
AlanAuch Observer
Posts : 162 Current Win Points : 34 Join date : 2010-12-12 Age : 41
Subject: Re: New TTA; Forecast Sat Apr 23, 2011 10:14 am
At first I wondered if the man outside the car was the same man we assumed to be a red herring in #31. I'm not sure if this video makes me more or less keen on the theory though
ChaosGamma Observer
Posts : 188 Current Win Points : 26 Join date : 2011-04-05 Age : 32 Location : Where I need to be
Subject: Re: New TTA; Forecast Sat Apr 23, 2011 10:20 am
Maybe Jay saw Totheark when he stopped to bring up a different song on his ipod?
Reach Untainted
Posts : 46 Current Win Points : 66 Join date : 2011-02-15 Age : 30
Subject: Re: New TTA; Forecast Sat Apr 23, 2011 1:29 pm
Alloflifedecays wrote:
I always like seeing this picture. I made the original one with only the first three, posted it on the MH Facebook group and now everyone uses it. It amuses me.
Incidentally, why is everyone so sure that Tim and TTA are involved at all? Shoot me if I'm wrong, but as far as I know Masky never appeared in any videos on TTA's channel, only in Entry #####, which we don't know was uploaded by TTA.
ChaosGamma Observer
Posts : 188 Current Win Points : 26 Join date : 2011-04-05 Age : 32 Location : Where I need to be
Subject: Re: New TTA; Forecast Sat Apr 23, 2011 2:16 pm
Masky was in the Warning video.
I think the similarity between that and Entry ###### is the reason most people figure it was Totheark that uploaded Entry ######. Or at the very least both of them were done by the same person (probably Totheark, but who knows anymore?)
Mr. Jeebles Slendervet
Posts : 1499 Current Win Points : 750 Join date : 2011-01-15 Age : 31 Location : Unknown
Subject: Re: New TTA; Forecast Sat Apr 23, 2011 3:35 pm
The thing is I think TTA is all three of them. Tim, Alex, and Jay It does not work for all of these entries to be just one of them. Also upon getting my MH DVD yesterday, I watched it with the TTA responses in chronological order. At Entry #13 when Alex tells Jay to get tapes from the car, he has a Slender Man encounter. WHILE Alex is busy with this, TTA posts the response video, Exit, which shows someone filming Jay at the car while Alex was busy with Slender Man.
Now knowing how far away the car is does poke some holes in here that Alex could have ran into Slender Man then become proxied and filmed that instead of Tim. My theory only really works as TTA being an antagonist person being proxied by Slender Man.
Reach Untainted
Posts : 46 Current Win Points : 66 Join date : 2011-02-15 Age : 30
Subject: Re: New TTA; Forecast Sat Apr 23, 2011 4:32 pm
ChaosGamma wrote:
Masky was in the Warning video.
I think the similarity between that and Entry ###### is the reason most people figure it was Totheark that uploaded Entry ######. Or at the very least both of them were done by the same person (probably Totheark, but who knows anymore?)
I don't think there all that similar to be honest. Also, Masky looks disoriented and not all there in Warning. I think it's more likely that TTA had managed to capture Tim and had him tied up and drugged or summat than TTA is working with him. He hasn't appeared in any TTA videos in a way that suggest they co-operated.
ChaosGamma Observer
Posts : 188 Current Win Points : 26 Join date : 2011-04-05 Age : 32 Location : Where I need to be
Subject: Re: New TTA; Forecast Sun Apr 24, 2011 6:34 pm
Well I didn't say I thought Tim was Totheark. Your idea about Totheark capturing him does seem possible. My idea about them working together has to do with Entry 19 and Return, since Totheark posts footage of Jay at the house after, presumably, Tim takes him there. It's possible, but I'm actually thinking more now that that's not it.
Now for random theorizing:
Tim can't be the one who walked by the car. I believe it said that was only a week after what happened at that building. I don't think Tim would be walking so well only a week after getting his leg smashed.
Alex is definitely a possibility, though I can't imagine what the purpose would be of doing that. Of course, whoever said any of this had to actually make sense?
The Operator, I suppose it could still be him but I doubt it. I do think it looks like the person was holding something, possibly a camera. And since it's clearly Totheark, well I mentioned before about the Operator appearing in Totheark's videos. I guess it could still be that Totheark is actually a group including the Operator, but I don't really think so at this time.
So that leaves us with, the rest of the Marble Hornets crew. And since all we really have on them is that Brian apparently disappeared or something, we really don't have anything to go on for them. It's very possibly that it could be Sarah or Seth, but then we also have no reason to suspect them.
I also had a theory about how Jessica could be Totheark, but honestly I don't think it's true and it's really kind of weak so I'm not going to post it.
Mr. Jeebles Slendervet
Posts : 1499 Current Win Points : 750 Join date : 2011-01-15 Age : 31 Location : Unknown
Subject: Re: New TTA; Forecast Sun Apr 24, 2011 8:28 pm
jakemcc wrote:
ummm hmmmmm maby its trying to tell someone something that maby its alive
Can you re-word that so the general population knows what you are talking about?
BlackWolf Watched
Posts : 279 Current Win Points : 99 Join date : 2010-12-19 Age : 37 Location : Somewhere