The minor theories thread

SuperRob45 wrote:

Something I'm thinking of, what if J is being possessed? What if he doesn't remember it because of the possession? It's just a thought, and I know that there is more to being possessed, and if he is, then it can't be a demon, obviously. If it were a demon possessing him it would more than likely start showing signs, darker eye lines, ect.

Like so?


Yes that's before the 7 months of missed time in the return video, but still that's my theory too. Jessica and J were going around doing the will of thy Operator, trolling other slenderstalked with those awesome masks.

Omega wrote:

DarkKaizer wrote:

Mr. Jeebles wrote:

DarkKaizer wrote:

Takes time to heal. It's obvious that a rock like that would deal more damage than what he appears to have been left with, even after 7 months.

Then what your saying depends on your definition of ascended being. IMO, an ascended being would be just about as immune as Slendy would be to a rock to the leg.

Ascended as in "something is working through his body". Not that he's actually BECOME a divine or unholy being. Just saying that with Slender Man (or something else) working through him, Tim would be more likely to heal from permanent injuries (such as a giant rock stabbing through your leg, leaving it permanently construed).

Also, would you like to imagine Masky going to a doctor? Don't really think that would fly myself.

But we haven't seen any instances of him healing faster; all we've seen are instances of him not healing faster.

Your claim entirely relies on the belief you have that A) We will see Masky again soon, and B) He will not be injured in any way when we see him, neither of which are claims you can support.

Not entirely on that belief. There's always the chance that the Maskies are being controlled with no regard of what happens to their mortal bodies.

Mr. Jeebles wrote:

SuperRob45 wrote:

Something I'm thinking of, what if J is being possessed? What if he doesn't remember it because of the possession? It's just a thought, and I know that there is more to being possessed, and if he is, then it can't be a demon, obviously. If it were a demon possessing him it would more than likely start showing signs, darker eye lines, ect.

Like so?


Yes that's before the 7 months of missed time in the return video, but still that's my theory too. Jessica and J were going around doing the will of thy Operator, trolling other slenderstalked with those awesome masks.

I forget, when entry was this video in?

SuperRob45 wrote:

Mr. Jeebles wrote:

SuperRob45 wrote:

Something I'm thinking of, what if J is being possessed? What if he doesn't remember it because of the possession? It's just a thought, and I know that there is more to being possessed, and if he is, then it can't be a demon, obviously. If it were a demon possessing him it would more than likely start showing signs, darker eye lines, ect.

Like so?


Yes that's before the 7 months of missed time in the return video, but still that's my theory too. Jessica and J were going around doing the will of thy Operator, trolling other slenderstalked with those awesome masks.

I forget, when entry was this video in?

totheark: Addition

SuperRob45 wrote:

...the side of his brain he's not using?

No such thing. That's a myth that was debunked a long time ago. We use all our brain; we just don't use it all at once.

DarkKaizer wrote:

SuperRob45 wrote:

Mr. Jeebles wrote:

SuperRob45 wrote:

Something I'm thinking of, what if J is being possessed? What if he doesn't remember it because of the possession? It's just a thought, and I know that there is more to being possessed, and if he is, then it can't be a demon, obviously. If it were a demon possessing him it would more than likely start showing signs, darker eye lines, ect.

Like so?


Yes that's before the 7 months of missed time in the return video, but still that's my theory too. Jessica and J were going around doing the will of thy Operator, trolling other slenderstalked with those awesome masks.

I forget, when entry was this video in?

totheark: Addition

Nope, it's from Return, but yes TTA was right.

DarkKaizer wrote:

Not entirely on that belief. There's always the chance that the Maskies are being controlled with no regard of what happens to their mortal bodies.

1) What are you supporting that with,
2) How does them not caring about their death support them being ascended beings?

Omega wrote:

No such thing. That's a myth that was debunked a long time ago. We use all our brain; we just don't use it all at once.

Well now I feel stupid.

Omega wrote:

DarkKaizer wrote:

Not entirely on that belief. There's always the chance that the Maskies are being controlled with no regard of what happens to their mortal bodies.

1) What are you supporting that with,
2) How does them not caring about their death support them being ascended beings?

1) Multiple Maskies. Being controlled by something.
2) Ascended may not be the right word... Something more along the lines of possessed. The higher power controlling the bodies might just not give a damn what happens to its hosts?

DarkKaizer wrote:

Omega wrote:

DarkKaizer wrote:

Not entirely on that belief. There's always the chance that the Maskies are being controlled with no regard of what happens to their mortal bodies.

1) What are you supporting that with,
2) How does them not caring about their death support them being ascended beings?

1) Multiple Maskies. Being controlled by something.
2) Ascended may not be the right word... Something more along the lines of possessed. The higher power controlling the bodies might just not give a damn what happens to its hosts?

First off, multiple maskies has not been proven. It's entirely speculation; there's nothing to back it up beyond that if could be possible. And there are a lot of things which could be possible that aren't.

Secondly, how would there being multiple maskies being controlled prove they don't care about death?

And finally, you didn't answer my question. I asked how you were supporting the idea that Tim/the maskies didn't care if they were killed. I wanted you to point out to me a moment(s) in Marble Hornets which could reasonably be construed as Tim acting in a way which proves he does not care if he dies. I wanted evidence which you were supporting your hypothesis with, not just more speculation.

So how exactly might he be controlling them?
Could he be making them think it's a dream, and controlling them through that? Like from a dream-like state. I mean it could explain the dark bags under his eyes.

He tackles J, even though he has a knife.

He attacks both J and Alex, even though it would be obvious that he couldn't overpower both of them.

He attacks J in the hotel, even with that limp of his.

Not saying he doesn't care if he dies, just saying that whatever is controlling him doesn't care if its vessel is "damaged".

DarkKaizer wrote:

He tackles J, even though he has a knife.

He attacks both J and Alex, even though it would be obvious that he couldn't overpower both of them.

He attacks J in the hotel, even with that limp of his.

Not saying he doesn't care if he dies, just saying that whatever is controlling him doesn't care if its vessel is "damaged".

J isn't exactly the most threatening person. Even when he brought a knife with him to the house, he didn't take it out, even after being attacked. And when Masky attacked J and Alex together, he did have a knife, which he did use, and it's fairly surprising that the two of them were able to subdue him without suffering serious injuries.

But say we accept that Tim doesn't care if he's injured/Slendy doesn't care/whatever's controlling him doesn't care. How do we then make the leap from that to "The Masky's have super human abilities"?

Well, their current powers seem to be:

1) Tackling fucking everything.
2) Scaring the shit out of people far more than what's capable of a normal person.
3) Distorting audio and video much the same way that Slendy does.

Of course, #3 is the only serious one on there, but still, that seems rather legit.

DarkKaizer wrote:

Well, their current powers seem to be:

1) Tackling fucking everything.
2) Scaring the shit out of people far more than what's capable of a normal person.
3) Distorting audio and video much the same way that Slendy does.

Of course, #3 is the only serious one on there, but still, that seems rather legit.

Causing audio/visual distortion definitely is something which the average person can't do, but where's the connection to having a healing factor?

Meh, guess I just disregarded the actual time it takes for a bone to heal. Still, I think he's doing damn good for a person who hasn't received medical attention.

"...a simple fracture, will take about six weeks to heal. Larger broken bones, for example the bones in the thigh, would take a great deal longer to heal, usually six weeks to three months in the average healthy adult."

SuperRob45 wrote:

"...a simple fracture, will take about six weeks to heal. Larger broken bones, for example the bones in the thigh, would take a great deal longer to heal, usually six weeks to three months in the average healthy adult."

Exactly, and the limp would come in from having no one to set it for him. Presumably he hasn't been able to see a doctor so it healed, but badly leaving him House'd.

Mr. Jeebles wrote:

....able to see a doctor so it healed, but badly leaving him House'd.

Moar leik... AN OPERATOR!!! [Dun Dun DUUUUUUUUUUUN!]

SuperRob45 wrote:

Mr. Jeebles wrote:

....able to see a doctor so it healed, but badly leaving him House'd.

Moar leik... AN OPERATOR!!! [Dun Dun DUUUUUUUUUUUN!]

Here, have a winpoint.

See, I just assumed that the distortion was caused by Slendy, even if the camera is on Masky. Just because you can't see him, doesn't mean he's nowhere near them...

Unless of course it's been proved that Masky DOES cause the distortion

DarkKaizer wrote:

Well, their current powers seem to be:

1) Tackling fucking everything.
2) Scaring the shit out of people far more than what's capable of a normal person.
3) Distorting audio and video much the same way that Slendy does.

Of course, #3 is the only serious one on there, but still, that seems rather legit.

1. Even I as a human, can tackle fucking everything. And trust me, I've even tackled someone so hard once that the force of the impact took down a bulletin board that was nailed to the fucking wall. Crazy thing was, I tackled him into the bulletin board. Oh school, how you get people into fights so easily.

2. "Normal" people can kill you without cryptic messages, or tackling, or "climbin' in yo windows". Death is scary. People can scare you in many other ways than just that. People can fuck with your phobias, or just downright scare you with the shit they say.

3. looby inb4'd me on it.

looby wrote:

See, I just assumed that the distortion was caused by Slendy, even if the camera is on Masky. Just because you can't see him, doesn't mean he's nowhere near them...

But to add on, don't most people who are Slenderized or who might have had contact with Slender Man(Jessica for example) get static when viewed most of the time? It's not just Masky who occasionally gets distortion around him. And even when they introduced Masky(AKA my first brickshitting in Marble Hornets), there wasn't static around him then or when Masky was in the house in the other entry where he came back.

DarkKaizer wrote:

Meh, guess I just disregarded the actual time it takes for a bone to heal. Still, I think he's doing damn good for a person who hasn't received medical attention.

And how do YOU know he hasn't gotten medical attention in the time after that to where he shows up again? It could be explained later that he went to a Hospital or something. You never know. When making theories, don't overlook what could be very obvious. TheVman guy already did that once

Spoiler:

Injuries hurt. Especially those kinds.

My theory: Masky is possessed by The Operator. When not being all Masky-like, he's just normal. Then when The Operator needs him, he "operates" Masky to do his will. Masky is a normal human, just under the control of The Operator. And no, I don't think there's multiple Masky people.

Zander wrote:

And even when they introduced Masky(AKA my first brickshitting in Marble Hornets), there wasn't static around him then or when Masky was in the house in the other entry where he came back.

*Shrug* Maybe they just didn't think of it at first?
Or maybe there could be two maskies? One posing as Maskie, while the other one is real?

Zander wrote:

My theory: Masky is possessed by The Operator. When not being all Masky-like, he's just normal. Then when The Operator needs him, he "operates" Masky to do his will. Masky is a normal human, just under the control of The Operator. And no, I don't think there's multiple Masky people.

Makes plenty of sense, especially considering #15. As for multiple maskies...well, I don't think there's more than one messing with Jay, but that weird bit of the tape Jay got in #26 pretty much proves that there's more than one crazy person running around in a mask (Tim ain't blonde). And they're somehow connected to whoever filmed that thing, which is probably someone that we already know.

SuperRob45 wrote:

Zander wrote:

And even when they introduced Masky(AKA my first brickshitting in Marble Hornets), there wasn't static around him then or when Masky was in the house in the other entry where he came back.

*Shrug* Maybe they just didn't think of it at first?
Or maybe there could be two maskies? One posing as Maskie, while the other one is real?

How? The fuck... A Masky POSING as Masky?!?! Did you eat a piece of atomic toast before posting! Anyone who is aware of Slendy in MH is a target. Slendy and the real Masky would not let some fucker run around playing tacklefuck all day. Yes it's quite possible there are other Maskies but no one is posing as Maskie, give Troy and Joseph some credit.

Please people base your theories on facts not stuff you pulled out of your ass.