Entry #35 Discussion

HOLY FUCKING SHIT. SPOILERS HERE:

Spoiler:

HOLYFUCKINGFUCKFUCKFUCKFUCK. CRAZIEST MH ENTRY? I THINK SO.

EDIT: And oh god, the scream.. I got chills from that...

I do believe, my dear people, that Tim had his head bashed in with the rock. HOWEVER, how could Masky have been in Jay's hotel room then?

Spoiler:

HOLY FUCKING SHIT FUCK WHAT FUCK?

Okay, so is...FUCK! I'm gonna have to come back tomorrow when I can think.

hahahahaha. I must say, MH is definitely picking back up.

THIS. JUST WHAT. THE. UH.
THANK GOD I STAYED UP.

I take back anything I said against Entry 34. Because THIS.
/mind blown

Spoiler:

*doesn't get your spoiler, sorry*

MY HEAD IS FULL OF FUCK AND I'M SHAKING ATM.......

Okay. First off, wow. Just...I never thought I would see anything like this on Marble Hornets. And yes, this changes a lot. Let's go through it in pieces, shall we?

May we thank the good Tube of Yous for spoiling that Alex is in this entry ALIVE.

Also, I loved how freaking bored and frustrated Jay sounds when the entry starts.

ALEX ALEX ALEX HI ALEX

OH SHIT MASKY

I THINK MASKY JUST STABBED ALEX

OH SHIT MASKY IS TIM, DUH

"NO I'M NOT GIVING YOU THE KNIFE"

OH MY GOD DID ALEX JUST BASH TIM'S HEAD IN

HOLY FUCKING SHITBALLS

...damn, I've watched it three times or so I keep having the same reaction. I'm still not sure how I feel about this entry. But I know it definitely explains Masky---Tim's limp in #33. Though I don't know how you DIE from being BLUDGEONED and come back with just a limp.

oh man, I just had the craziest theory ever: Alex and Jay kidnap Tim and go all 24 on his ass to learn more about the Operator. Torture him until he talks. But I don't think that's what happened.

Can anyone make out what Alex says just before the camera cuts to Jay? "he's not gonna--"?

BONUS THEORY WHILE I'M AT IT: The Operator stopped Alex from killing Tim and transported Jay to his car.

Watisthisidonteven.
This changes EVERYTHING.

Spoiler:

Crackpot theory; Resurection makes you fat.

......................................

D8


I literally screamed when Masky Tim came out from around the corner like that.

And Alex is alive? That's what was on those tapes?!??!?!

;lajf;aslkdfja;dslfj!!!!

Oh shit....this just opens up a whole new can of worms then, doesn't it....?

Maybe Lisa was right....there's more than one Masky.....I mean, it would explain why he came back....and it looks like I was wrong about Masky maybe wanting to help Jay....it's seeming more likely now that he wants to hurt him...even though he tried to protect him by not giving Alex the knife.......

Oh man, my head's reeling right now...I just....I don't know what to say.....shit.....

Alice wrote:

Can anyone make out what Alex says just before the camera cuts to Jay? "he's not gonna--"?

I believe I hear "He's not gonna follow us" or something close to that. So with memory loss, the return of Alex and death (or retirement) of the original Masked, this is an interesting change in the theory. Hopefully ToTheArk will entertain us with another clue.

And until 36 or something else show me different, I believe Jessica or Alex may be the other Masked. We shall see.

@Alice, I think he said "He's not gonna follow us," though I might be wrong.

We don't get to see where he brings it down, but it's possible he just brings it down on the leg, not the head. I mean, I'd probably scream like that if someone broke my leg with a fucking rock.

Also, note: As he leaves, Alex isn't with Jay. Jay's not talking to anyone. If they left together, they'd almost definitely have some words to exchange. So since he set out to try to find Alex, here's the question: why did he take off alone once he found him?

To summarize:

-Jay visits house from Entry #34, still doesn't see anything, starts getting frustrated.

-Alex comes in behind Jay, signaling him to look out in the room ahead.

-Masky/Tim charges out with a knife in hand, apparently slashing Alex's right arm as we hear him scream off camera and see blood later.

-Alex slams Tim to the ground like a fucking boss, Jay hands Alex some rope to tie Tim up and removes the mask.

-Alex is pissed now, and asks Jay to give him the knife. Jay refuses.

-Without missing a beat, Alex picks up a huge chunk of stone, tells Jay to turn off the camera, lifts the stone over Tim's head, exclaims "HE IS NOT GONNA FOLLOW US!", we hear a horrific scream, aaand cut. Back to Jay driving.


Biggest highlights for me: Tim being conclusively revealed as Masky, Jay showing emotion, Alex BEING A FUCKING BADASS.

So now we're left with two big questions regarding Tim:

1) How did he survive to appear in Entry #33? Alex apparently bludgeoned him with a big fucking rock.

2) Is he totheark?

Hoping for an interesting TTA response.

:X I think the broken leg theory explains both limp and weight gain in #33. In the months since then, Tim could have been bed ridden, and thus put on the weight.

It would seem to me Jay had found Alex a good while before this entry occurred. Just the way they're acting seems to me like they planned this trip.

Did the Masked have a limp in #33?

I can't tell. His/her hair seems different, he/she seems thicker in frame then the first Masked, and I'm not saying this due to #35

Thanks for the monkey wrench to all my theories...

I got goose bumps when Alex just appeared in the door way.

THIS SHIT JUST GOT AWESOME.

I hope updates start coming quickly.

HorrorJuku wrote:

:X I think the broken leg theory explains both limp and weight gain in #33. In the months since then, Tim could have been bed ridden, and thus put on the weight.

Horror makes a good point. :3 This might explain why we saw what we saw in Entry #33.

Look back at #29.

Bloody rock. About the size maybe of the one used to attack the Masked?

That rock looks a little big for it, but it might be the same rock. Nice catch, Hunter!



The rock's about at 0:48.

I agree the rock seems...different. But, this 'noentry' maybe happening after the events of #35.

Maybe with the assault of his tool, Slender shows up and makes Alex and Jay split. Why was the camera man in 29 with two camera? That was Jay's chest rig...so, hmm. More to ponder on.

PARADOX intent wrote:

That rock looks a little big for it, but it might be the same rock. Nice catch, Hunter!

Thank you, good sir. Only the observations of a lowly man. But, thank you. ^^

.................. I love this entry.

I can't even... I have to watch it again.

The Hunter wrote:

PARADOX intent wrote:

That rock looks a little big for it, but it might be the same rock. Nice catch, Hunter!

Thank you, good sir. Only the observations of a lowly man. But, thank you. ^^

I'm technically a ma'am, but I'll let this one slide. XD

And, yeah. Only time will tell with the rock.

PARADOX intent wrote:

I'm technically a ma'am, but I'll let this one slide. XD

And, yeah. Only time will tell with the rock.

Forgive me, ma'am. I didn't see the dress. ^^