Entry #35 Discussion

did anyone else notice that instead of lunging at the first person he saw (jay, who was right in in face with a camera) like a normal... crazy person would, masky/tim went right around jay in favor of attacking alex?? i'm kind of wondering the implications of this...

this could very well be chalked up to 'masky/tim is crazy and doesnt have to make sense', but i thought it was worth noting anyway

^ No, I noticed that too and was thinking about it for awhile.

I still have no idea what it means though. Maybe Tim's out for revenge for something Alex did? I don't know... But yeah, that was definitely interesting and I'm glad I wasn't the only one that noticed.

The missing link to the Hotel mess, the Return Address House, and the missing 7 months or so of memories is in Jessica.

In her room we had: The unlock code to Jay's Safe. Did she place those videos of Jay and Alex in there? Did Jay put them in there, and left the code with Jessica before he lost his memory?

Those strange noises all those nights are trouble-some, and she is going through the same turmoil as Jay, and Alex. Memory loss, sleep walking, etc.

The next video Jay uploads I hope lights up the connection to Jessica and the others.

When her story is explained, the end might be near.

Also, what may have happened to Alex's GF from #26? Will she be a figure in the puzzle, or just another victim?
Eh, I'm too tired for this...

bilo wrote:

I still have no idea what it means though. Maybe Tim's out for revenge for something Alex did? I don't know...

same here. i thought of that too, but what could alex have done to tim that could warrant such aggression?? it would make more sense the other way around (that said, alex was pretty intent on maiming tim near the end there...). from what we've seen of tim/masky so far, it's pretty unusual for him to be using a knife in the first place. every time he's attacked jay, it's been bare handed as far as i can remember. correct me if i'm wrong, tho^^'

it seemed to me that tim wasnt expecting alex to be there, and once tim figured out that he was (jay isnt exactly one to talk to himself other than the occaisional scared 'hello?' lolz), decided to try to take him out of the equation

on the other hand, tho, the fact that tim had the knife out and ready to go could mean that he was indeed expecting alex to be there. there seemed to be quite a gap between 34 and 35, and since jay and alex seem to have met up at some point in between, who knows how much masky could have been spying on them?? he could have known well ahead of time that they were coming

aaaand on the third hand, there's the idea that alex just popped up in the house out of nowhere. tho from the way jay acted, i severely doubt it (pretty sure he'd spaz if that was the first time he'd seen his friend in years, creepy house or no)

ughh, so many theories, so little time before bed @_@ i dont know what to think at this point. all i know is that attack definitely seemed aimed at alex, and i'm very curious as to what exactly alex was trying to get jay to see there in the first place

*end rambling*

So Tim went straight for Alex. With a knife. He avoided Jay. Alex hurt Tim badly to keep him from following the two of them.

Anyone else here realize Masky is seeing Alex as a threat and wants him to stay away from Jay? And that Alex knows this and wants to keep Tim from protecting Jay?

DUN DUN DUN. My lame theory. I suck at theories.

Nedark wrote:

That, and it is also rather difficult to scream with your brains splattered on the ground.

Just sayin'.

Oh. I thought the scream came before the rock smash.

everlot1000 wrote:

Jessica is in no way masky. I have a theory about that in one of my other posts.

There are people who thought Jessica was masky? O__o

MadameMiz wrote:

aaaand on the third hand

I myself have three hands... >.>

And yeah, there were some people who thought Jessica was Masky for awhile. Didn't make much sense to me either but. ashdjah There you go.

Finally got to see the video after borrowing someone's iPhone thingy.

And while everyone else already said this five pages ago, HOLY SHIT TIM'S MASKY I SO KNEW IT!


Although I'm doubting that Alex killed Masky. Broken leg feels more likely to me, honestly.

Awesome

Masky made me almost fall out of my chair in surprise.
I was however, surprised to see someone else coming in.
And.. BIG ROCK.. yeah, that part made me cringe.
What'd they do with the mess? You don't hit someone with something that big and not leave a trace of some sort either in the area or on yourself <,<

qwertyuasdsfdgdswd


Been sick just NOW saw this. Holy shit, holy shit.. At first I was like ohshitisthatalex??

I did jump a bit when Masky popped out...

HAHA TIM! I knew it!


NOOOOO MASKY!!!!!

Have any of you guys ever broken your leg? It is the most painful experience I have ever had to go through and would not wish it upon anyone, especially the way it happened to me. Crossing the street at a jog, I collided with the side of a moving van, spun around from the force, then proceeded to try to walk to regain my balance. The bone broke through my skin. The dent where that occured, plus the area around it, will forever be numb and if I bruise that dent or anywhere around it, I limp for the next 2 to 4 days.

After rewatching #33, I see the limp that everyone has been talking about. It even looks like he's leaning up against the wall for support. From my own experiences, either he did not recieve any medicial treatment (in my case, it was two screws, about thirteen staples and four stitches, which is probably around what he would have needed) or he recently REdamaged it.

Again, from my own experiences with this, if he is leaning like that, it means his left leg, close to the ankle was broken, which is EXACTLY where mine was...which makes it even creepier! Yes, it would make more sense to shatter his knees, but I do not believe that Alex would have it in him to do that to someone, even someone who may be after him or Jay. That would be permanent damage and if he's doing that to one leg, why not both?

Alex is NOT the type of person who just acts spontaneously. This was well thought out and well put into play.

even tho this seems a bit out of character for alex, i do think he was trying to kill tim (or at the very least, put him out of commission for a very long time); i just dont think he succeeded. i'm thinking either alex somehow spectacularly failed on his aim, tim managed to dodge, or jay intervened, and the result was an injury to tim's leg

it's true that under normal circumstances, a leg would heal within 7 months, but keep in mind the conditions that tim seems to live under. i cant imagine him just waltzing into a hospital for proper care. it just seems like this is the most likely way to explain the limp in #33

either way, it makes much more sense than the 'slendy resurrection' theory e.e i'm still not even convinced that slendy and masky r on the same side

MadameMiz wrote:

it's true that under normal circumstances, a leg would heal within 7 months, but keep in mind the conditions that tim seems to live under. i cant imagine him just waltzing into a hospital for proper care. it just seems like this is the most likely way to explain the limp in #33

That is true, Masky, (well, Tim) can't really go to a hospital, I mean, whats he going to say? "I slashed a guy with a knife and then he bashed my leg in with a rock, lololol' Slender must have given him some pills or something, but it couldn't be fully healed.

Yup, Timasky does love his pills.


And, Madame, please refer to my avatar. I hate to be the one to say it, but I just can't fucking stand it.

I'm kinda getting a feeling Mr. Slenderman was there. There was some distortion there, and I can totally see Slender walking in right after Alex bashes Tim's head/leg.

RocktheworldXD wrote:

I'm kinda getting a feeling Mr. Slenderman was there. There was some distortion there, and I can totally see Slender walking in right after Alex bashes Tim's head/leg.

Wut? Where the hell did you see Slendy? I didn't see him...

PARADOX intent wrote:

RocktheworldXD wrote:

I'm kinda getting a feeling Mr. Slenderman was there. There was some distortion there, and I can totally see Slender walking in right after Alex bashes Tim's head/leg.

Wut? Where the hell did you see Slendy? I didn't see him...

Haha, I didn't mean literally. I meant it in a kind of "I wish this would happen/that would be kind of cool" way. Sorry for the confusion.

quofomo wrote:

Slender must have given him some pills or something, but it couldn't be fully healed.

hmm, i think you're thinking of our slender friend in a way that's far too humanistic. i'm not saying it's impossible, but MH seems to take the eldritch abomination route for the operator; i cant quite picture their slendy magically producing a bottle of pills out of nowhere. still not convinced tim and slendy are on the same side anyway. but most theories are equally valid at this point, i suppose

the leg probably would be healed... just very, very badly. and painfully e_e

quofomo wrote:

And, Madame, please refer to my avatar. I hate to be the one to say it, but I just can't fucking stand it.

haha no worries, i'm a horrible speller by nature. but, err, unless you're refering to the fact that i dont capitalize and use apostrophes in some words, i really dont know what you're seeing ._.' either way, sorry if it bothers you so much

RocktheworldXD wrote:

PARADOX intent wrote:

RocktheworldXD wrote:

I'm kinda getting a feeling Mr. Slenderman was there. There was some distortion there, and I can totally see Slender walking in right after Alex bashes Tim's head/leg.

Wut? Where the hell did you see Slendy? I didn't see him...

Haha, I didn't mean literally. I meant it in a kind of "I wish this would happen/that would be kind of cool" way. Sorry for the confusion.

Ooooh. Kay. See, this needs to be pointed out for me. XD I'm a bit slow when it comes to matters like this.

Remember in entry 33? He had a limp
Maybe Tim moved out of the way fast enough to only get hit in the leg?

Zhanro wrote:

Remember in entry 33? He had a limp
Maybe Tim moved out of the way fast enough to only get hit in the leg?

You didn't read the thread did you? That's OK, but as a future reference make sure your theory hasn't already been posted.

Ok guys so first things first, Timasky had a knife, now where do you think he got this knife? I don't kno, maybe Jays knife from their first encounter maybe? Jay said his knife was gone.
Number 2) Timasky dodged Jay and went for Alex yes? what if Tim is protecting Jay from Alex who is Slendy-Controlled? I mean think about it, If all of their encounters, Jay threw the first blow, save for their first. But again, Say that Slendy was around at that first encounter and Tim pushed Jay out of the way and was affected instead?
Just some theories to throw around.

wow horrible spelling sorry, but look past the spelling errors please?

AwesumSaurusRex wrote:

Number 2) Timasky dodged Jay and went for Alex yes? what if Tim is protecting Jay from Alex who is Slendy-Controlled? I mean think about it, If all of their encounters, Jay threw the first blow, save for their first. But again, Say that Slendy was around at that first encounter and Tim pushed Jay out of the way and was affected instead?
Just some theories to throw around.

That's what I posted one page back...

Sanne wrote:

AwesumSaurusRex wrote:

Number 2) Timasky dodged Jay and went for Alex yes? what if Tim is protecting Jay from Alex who is Slendy-Controlled? I mean think about it, If all of their encounters, Jay threw the first blow, save for their first. But again, Say that Slendy was around at that first encounter and Tim pushed Jay out of the way and was affected instead?
Just some theories to throw around.

That's what I posted one page back...

sorry brah, i always thought that to be the real truth O.o

RocktheworldXD wrote:

I'm kinda getting a feeling Mr. Slenderman was there. There was some distortion there, and I can totally see Slender walking in right after Alex bashes Tim's head/leg.

There have been instances where Masky himself causes distortions. I don't think anyone can say whether Slendy was there.